|
Post by goten0040 on May 22, 2006 13:21:04 GMT -5
Siani
Sig
Color: 9/10, I'm a sucker for firelight. I really am. I love reds and oranges, especially on Zuko. ^^ Stock Choice/Cutting: Um... I don't know what this means... >>; (And I'm a mod! How depressing. U_u) Text: 8/10, Simple but effective and I can read it! ^^ Also dig the fade-in text bg. Technique: 8/10, again, simple but effective. Simplicity can sometimes be better than the others. Quality of Image: 10/10, good quality picture! You must have gotten it off firebender. ^^ But Zuko's flipped isn't he? ^^ Overall: 9/10
Avatar
Color: Again, I'm a sucker for fire colors. 9/10 Stock Choice/Cutting: See above... ^^; Text: Good chinese text (where'd you get it?) but the english is a bit hard to read. 7/10 Technique: 8/10 It works well as an avatar, even if a bit small when crushed to 100x100 pixels. Quality of Image: Due to the change in size, the image looks quite a bit blurry, but the colors still pop. 8/10 Overall: 8/10
|
|
firephoenixflame
Teo
Toko StableMistress
Xia's Angels - Saving the Ava-verse.. One Mary Sue at a time. Rai, Jia, Kura -- GO!
Posts: 433
|
Post by firephoenixflame on May 22, 2006 14:08:51 GMT -5
Goten0040
Sig
Color: 7/10 It looks very washed out. Probably that is due to the fact that it is a dream sequence. However, I would have liked to see some contrast and color correction. I also think that there is something faded over the image which could attribute to this. Stock Choice/Cutting: 9/10 My biggest point is that Ursa's beautiful face is cover by text and that could have been fixed if the image had been moved to the right. Text: 7/10 The color again is too dark for it to really stand out. The Red makes it hard to read against the darker image despite the white dropshadow. Technique: 7/10 A above average signature. At least it's a good size and not huge like some I've seen. It was resized correctly enough to retain it's correct porpotions. The colors are the weak point here. overall: 7/10
Avatar
Color: 8/10. Kudos for the brightness of the colors, but other than that. There's no theme or relation through color Stock Choice/Cutting: 2/10 The low score is because the image is so squished. It's such a simple thing to fix too.. makes my adobe photoshop loving heart cry everytime I see an image that could have been fixed with a simple transform command. Also, the lines and details come across as choppy, a result of the resizing. Text: 6/10 - Points for the positioning, but negatives on the color choice. it blends into much. A nice stroke, or white droplight would have helped add some depth Technique: 5/10 It's a basic avatar. I understand that not everyone posses Photosop like I do so.. I can forgive the squashing. Quality of Image: 2/10 I can only assume that this image looks good at full size, but shrunk to 100X100 without cropping it loses all it's quality Overall: 4/10
|
|
|
Post by Confettie on Jun 1, 2006 13:42:19 GMT -5
Sig Color: 10/10 The color flows from blue/gray/black very beautifully. The outer-glow of the image doesn't hurt either. Also blue my favorite color. Stock Choice/Cutting: 9/10 I see three images and their cut well no background lines anywhere. Text: 6/10 The text is pretty much just use as an enhancer for the sig. It's really unreadable. Technique: 9/10 I see you use the gradient tool, the overlay feature, and outer-glow. Also you took your time selecting images that would work for your sig and crop them out nicely. Quality of Image: 9/10 The picture is very clear it's just the lettering on the bottom is unreadable. Overall: 9/10
Avatar Color: 9/10 The blue is really pretty as again my favorite color Stock Choice/Cutting: 6/10 The girl is cut out well but the annoying Chinese's writing to the side of her head. It not cut well and looks like a dancing lizard ghost. Text: 6/10 It's a creative idea to use Chinese writing but the positioning of it isn't well. Also the opacity of it make it not look like Chinese writing but some other picture. Technique: 5/10 You really didn't do much. The background is a solid color with a brush I think from Forbidden Fire I have that one on my computer too. Then that same crop image of the women with a drop shadow. Then the writing overlay or screen on top. Quality of Image: 7/10 the girl is visible, but that writing on the side isn't. Overall: 6/10
|
|
|
Post by almighty on Jun 8, 2006 1:10:27 GMT -5
Color: 10/10, blue being my favorite color. I like how it isn't pure blue and that it has different shades which gives it contrast. Stock Choice/Cutting: 10/10 Good. Its glowy, clean, and fits perfectly. Text: 10/10. The text is my favorite part. It's so different from other sigs who normally have the text off to the side. Very good. Technique: 9/10, Although it looks sweet and simple, I know that it takes skills to make it come out that way. I actually like the glowy effect and the background very much. Only thing I would suggest working on is maybe the border.... it looks a bit too.... bold for such a soft sig. Quality of Image: 10/10,very good. Overall: 10/10, I cannot rate any lower than this. Kadaj and friends are soooo cool. Not to mention the sig looks mighty different from the other sigs I've seen. Great Job!!
Avatar
Color: 10/10, Nice variety. Teal, purple, white, etc. Nice gradients. Stock Choice/Cutting: 10/10, Very clean... very crisp. Text: 6/10... I can't read it... erm... if its meant to be read. Technique: 10/10, looks like the work of a professional. I love the fading... it gives the avie a subtle feeling and at the same time, the crispness of the picture gives the avie boldness. Quality of Image: 10/10 ^See Stock... Overall: 10/10, What can I say, I just love the prince. XD Yes... that and your avie. It definitely shows some skill and it is just so pretty to look at. Not to mention the border is so much more different from what I've seen. Great job!!!!!
|
|
|
Post by goten0040 on Jun 9, 2006 19:32:39 GMT -5
Almighty
Avatar
Color: 9/10 I like the colors, very soft yet very bold. ^^ Stock Choice/Cutting: 10/10 It works. Captures everything in the right area. Text: N/A There is no text. Technique: 9/10 Very simple though I think it'd be prettier without the little translucent squares Quality of Image: 8/10 The translucent squares blur the quality of the image. Overall: 9/10
Sig
Color: 7/10 and 8/10 The colors are blotchy and don't match each other as well as they could. A bit overdone in the color field on both. Stock Choice/Cutting: 10/10 No problems in either. Text: 7/10 and 9/10 The text is really hard to read in the first one, but not as much in the second. Technique: 8/10 Interestingly done. I haven't seen many sigs done that way. Quality: 8/10 and 9/10 The first one is overshadowed by all the extra stuff. The second one is better in that area. Overall: 8/10 and 9/10
|
|
|
Post by Confettie on Jun 12, 2006 14:00:33 GMT -5
For Goten0040 Avatar Color: 8/10 I like the fading effect of all the images it flows smoothly into one another. Though the flashes of color coming from your name does hurt the eyes. Stock Choice/Cutting: 10/10 I like your artwork and you did a good job of displaying all of them without making it to clutter. Text: 5/10 I'm not fond of the text mostly the animated blinking of your name. I think a gradual fade between all of the color of your Avatar would have been awesome and a better choice instead of a blinking blue to red. Or is it some Zutara thing red and blue?? If it is creative, but still hurts the eyes. Technique: 8/10 It's animated and I don't see that much animated avatar anymore. Also the fading and the cropping out of all the images. Quality of Image: 9/10 It's clear Overall: 8/10 sig Color: 9/10 I like the color it matches Zuko well. Stock Choice/Cutting: 7/10 Zuko and the image of the two in the middle is cut well. Katara on the other hand has that one area in between her face and hair that hasn't been cut out. It's rather annoying because the sig is generally a fiery color while that area is blue. Text: 9/10 visible and creative Technique: 8/10 for the cropping of the image, I see the overlay lines on top which match your text well, original, and I haven't seen anyone else on the forum with a sig like yours. Quality of Image: 7.5/10 The Zuko on the left image is rather low quality. It's really gradient and ruins the high quality images of Karata and the one in which they're holding hands. Overall: 8/10
|
|
|
Post by Zukosfire5 on Jun 14, 2006 13:41:06 GMT -5
Avvie: Color:8/10. The colors go together, but in my opinion they sorta compete for attention also. Stock Choice/Cutting: 9/10. The person looks really cool, and what I can see of her pose makes her look somewhat exotic (for lack of a better word) Text: 8/10. A littl hard to read, but I do like the effect on it with the cross through. Technique: 9/10. The swirl looks very pretty, and I can tell whoever made this spent a lot of time on it. Quality of Image: 9/10. Obviously this was worked hard on Overall: 8/10
Sig #1 Color: 10/10. The blues give it a soft yet fierce look. Very pretty. Stock Choice/Cutting: 9/10. The people in the sig blend in nicely, but you can still clearly see them. Text: 8/10. Once again, a little hard to read. Technique: 9/10. It looks really cool and mysterious. Quality of Image: 10/10. Once again, work was really put into this. Overall: 9/10
Sig #2 Color: 9/10. I like how the colors are very defined, and the color scheme of creams and reds stand out. Stock Choice/Cutting: 8/10. I love Zuko, and Song is a good character in herself. Despite the fact I don't support Soko, the two pictures right next to each other work well with each other. Text: 9/10. You can read it fairly well, and the font is pretty cool. Technique: 9/10. I like the two pictures with each other, and the quote used is very suitable. I also really like the background. Quality of Image: 10/10. It's a very nice looking sig. Overall: 9/10
|
|
Akash
FN Aang
Posts: 1,857
|
Post by Akash on Jun 14, 2006 14:19:38 GMT -5
Avatar - Color: 10/10 it goes with the theme "soldiers" Stock Choice/Cutting: 9/10 Simply amazing and precise except for Toph's head XD Text: 10/10 it's a bit faded at the very right, but I don't really care Technique: 10/10 the idea is creative and you did it well Quality of Image: 9/10 It could be a bit smoother with the animation but that might be really hard to do. Overall: 10/10!
Siggy- Color: 9/10 I like the read but it makes my eyes hurt... it's probably because I have red-green defeciancy .___. Stock Choice/Cutting: 10/10 You cut awesomely! Text: The text at the very cool! The main text is a bit hard to read though 9/10 Technique: 10/10 I like it! Quality of Image: 10/10 no blurs or nothing! Overall: 9.5/10 Few things don't click with me but it's very nicely done!!
|
|