Judge One:
Sikrinerk
Because I was given Sikrinerk's link early on in the challenge, I was able to see that their work process was one with no tribal squables. Somebody took leadership into their hands early on, and amazingly there was no fighting! And hey, I'd say it looks pretty nice, too.
Obvious effort was put into the creation of the island, and the moderate discussing of tactics is already taking place.
However, I do feel the need to take a few points off. The lack of security on your island could result in spies, raids, etc. I suggest taking a few steps to up the security! XD
Over all I give Sikrinerk a 7/10
Donoma
This was the one tribe that I was NOT able to use my super secret spy powers on. XD Great job keeping everything secret! Your island is virtually untrackable, and you have some GREAT ideas on how to make it even better. You broke away from the popular idea on how to do things--- I predicted that everybody would do the same thing, but alas, you took a chance and was creative with the challenge and obviously thought it through a LOT. Nobody would ever find you, that I am certain of.
I can only see one small problem, and it is so minor I can barely dock you. XD
I give Donoma a 9.5/10
Mainit
Mainit, You need to make many improvements if your site is going to be functional. First of all, hints of what your island is around the forum does not make for a very secure island. XD "Our site is almost done!" This implies that it is a *Site*. Not a chat, not an AIM room, nothing like that. It just makes it that much easier to figure out what your island is.
Second of all, the actual SITE is not secure. At all. It's easily searchable and I found it within the first minute that I looked. Once you actually navigate TO the island, you can just get right in!
Third of all, the content. Come on, guys. 3/4 of the stuff there wasn't about your tribe. You have one little section? It's supposed to be focused on your tribe. XD
FOURTH OF ALL, PG, Guys!!! DH Survivor is a *DH EVENT*. I know your island is on another site, but Survivor is an extention of DH.
I suggest you make some changes.
I give Mainit a 5/10.
Muany
Ah, Muany. The rocky start and the lack of leadership or communication put you at a very solid last place from the beggining. However, you came out of that rut, and started talking about what needed to happen. Then, somebody took control and relocated.
The new island is possibly everything that I was looking for---At least for that particular type of island, which was doomed to be called a lack of creativity from the beggining XD
Actually, I found that your new island was PERFECTLY SECURE! With just the right touch of creativity, too. Not so much the way it LOOKED, but how much you thought it out! From the names to the very thoughtful judge account, I luff it.
You're discussing tactics ALREADY and you have a huge head start this early in the game. I was pleasently surprised, and you pulled yourself right out of a rut.
I give Muany an 8.5/10
Judge Two:
sikrinerk
Hmm, what to say, what to say...
First of all, it's nice that your island has developed a hierarchy system and a leader. Unfortunately, from what I've read, it seems that your island is extremely problematic as it is filled with inner conflict. I also am not fond of the layout. I'm glad you have a job system.
how I vew your island: A cannibalistic/member sacrificing island that is strict and tough on its own in order to keep order. Members violently fight each other to gain higher levels on the member hierarchy.
4/10
Donoma
I was going to subtract points for giving me frustration in viewing the island but I'm impressed by your level of secrecy. However, it's quite a dismay to see that it's simple rather than what most people would do, since other systems tend to seem more organized. Also you guys have no skin or attractive aesthetics.
How I view your island: A black metal box with members gathered around a hole which shay sends challenges through confines secret discussions and bleak features.
7/10
Mainit: I like your organization and skin coloring. But you seem to have a hard time running your island. It's as if you're being run by a one-person steed. You seem to have a critical problem with maintaining living members though. I do question your secuirty, other islands can easily spy and pry.
My view: Your island has been afflicted with some ailment or curse that's plaguing and destroying everyone. It seems that in this chaotic time only one member is able to pull the island together. But, will his carelessness cost you?
5.5/10
Muany:
My, oh my, how simply protected you guys are. Also, your team seems rather cohesive with a considerate leader. I like the graphical stuff of your island, simiply adorable. but simply lacking.
My view: Your island is "okay" in aesthetics but boring and desolate. But your leadership and family style cohesion is admirable. You're a family that will stay together no matter how horrible everything else is.
7.5/10
Judge Three:
Sikrinerk (wtfthesenamesarehardtotype)K, first of all I didn't really like the layout, but I guess that isn't really that important. They really do deserve extra points for the cool add ons on their island.
I would make it a member only island though, this makes raids too easy.They really are very organized and I like the way they split the work and try to get through the challenges using teamwork.
Sikrinerk: 6/10DonomaOh, look, they didn't use proboards!
I really think this type of island is more useful for this kind of discussion, so I think it was a pretty good idea, plus it makes them stand out a little bit. =D
I may be hard to find the island, the only problem is that once someone does, he/she can read everything without even needing a password. Oh well, if Shay couldn't find it, let's assume nobody can
.
Donoma:8/10MainitThe Layout isn't that bad, and the chat addon is awesome.
The island could be a bit more about DH survivor though, it doesn't look like an island, more like some random place with a lot of useless spam.
The island is begging to be raided though, members only plz!
Mainit: 4/10MuanyCan you spell puuurrrfect?
Great layout, great discussion and protection against raids/spies.
Muany: 10/10Judge Four:
SikrinerkThe island has a very nice style to it... somewhat calming and relaxing.
The music soothed my ears too~
Overall I think its a good place for you guys to get together and chat about the events. =D Though, you could use a bit of your team colors...?
Sikrinerk -- 9/10DonomaVery well hidden! Oh! Its original! A very unique island~
Great use of team colors and time!
It gets tiring waiting for people to post!
Well hidden as well. ;]
Donoma -- 10/10MainitYou used team colors and the layout is nice--
but as Shay said, it's too easy to find, plus then random people will sign up, won't they?
Mainit -- 6/10MuanyNice style! It's clever and hard to find!
Colors are well used and it is productive.
Nice work!
Muany -- 10/10Total Results
Sikrinerk: 26/40Donoma: 34.5/40Mainit: 20.5/40Muany: 36/40Which puts Muany in first, Donoma in second, Sikrinerk in third, and Mainit in last place.
I'm sorry Mainit, but you're heading to Tribal council. Info on tribal council will be in the next post.
And to everyone else---Wonderful job! You have evaded tribal council for this challenge.