Icon Discussion #3

[West]

Icon Discussion #3

How This All Works...

I will post a new icon on Friday night/Saturday for these discussions. Each icon will be left up in the discussion thread for about a week, so you all can freely talk about whatever you want (that pertains to the icon).



Rules

01. Anyone is allowed to post in this thread, as long as it is to discuss said icon.
02. When making your comments, try to have both good and bad aspects of the icon.
03. Do not bash, or make fun of another icon.
04. Keep it kid-friendly. No swear words.
05. Respect other people's opinions. You are free to disagree, but you may not bash someone else's opinion.
06. Feel free to be bluntly honest. This thread isn't here to hurt feelings, but it is to discuss icons, whether you think that they are good or bad.
07. Have a fun time critiquing.



When making your post, I would like you to have at least table filled out. I also have the coding at the end, so you can just copy and paste it into your post:
When filling in your scores, please make them on a scale of 1 - 10, 10 being the best (highest), and 1 being the worst (lowest).

Areas of Critique	Score (1-10)
Crop	--
Coloring	--
Brushes/ Textures	--
Text	--
TOTAL:	--

Please only fill out the score box if it is applicable; meaning if there is not text on the icon, then leave that box blank.
[ text consists of placement, coloring, font, etc. TINY TEXT DOES NOT COUNT AS TEXT! ]


[center][table][tr][td]Areas of Critique[/td][td]Score (1-10) [/td][/tr]
[tr][td][center]Crop[/center][/td][td][center]--[/center][/td][/tr]
[tr][td][center]Coloring[/center][/td][td][center]--[/center][/td][/tr]
[tr][td][center]Brushes/
  Textures[/center][/td][td][center]--[/center][/td][/tr]
[tr][td][center]Text[/center][/td][td][center]--[/center][/td][/tr]
[tr][td][center][b]TOTAL:[/b][/center][/td][td][center]--[/center][/td][/tr][/table][/center]

[~*~WhItEsHeEp~*~]

Areas of Critique	Score (1-10)
Crop	8
Coloring	10
Brushes/ Textures	7
Text	5
TOTAL:	30

I like the roku and the colors, but something about the text looks funky to me. I think maybe that its just so perfect and precisely in the middle, but thats just me.

[West]

Ok, I already foresaw that this would happen. These are now, only after having three, becoming dead. This makes me sad. =[

[Scarlett Ember]

Areas of Critique	Score (1-10)
Crop	9
Coloring	10
Brushes/ Textures	7
Text	6
TOTAL:	32

I really like the style. I like how it is cut in half with the red and text on top with the image on the bottom, while Roku is on top of both halves. I like the glow as well, but I don't like the quality of the Roku image. Just looks like a low quality, but otherwise I like it.